The Democracy Corps, my favorite polling firm has just released a new national poll on illegal immigration. In their gem of a memo based on the poll results, the pollsters come to several conclusions that are important for Democrats to grasp especially in Northern Virginia and here in Prince William County.
The first one that jumps out at me is that voters are looking for solutions after an era of Republican majorities failing to solve our major problems and that a solution for illegal immigration must be able to build upon our immigrant tradition. It is clear that candidates can not afford to sweep this aside.
They mention the following elements that Democrats need to highlight in their position on this issue:
“• Recognition of the problem: ‘get it.’ Candidates ignore the issue at their peril. It is Essential to convey an appreciation that illegal immigration is out of control and needs to be addressed immediately and seriously. If leaders do not show their own
frustration with the problem, they will not be heard on this issue – and many others.
• Attack Bush for losing control of the problem. A strong critique of the Bush
administration’s failure to address this issue shows that we understand the problem
and empathize with voters’ frustration with the lack of leadership on this issue.
• Enforcement at both the border and with employers. Voters believe that controls at the borders and enforcement in the workplace have disappeared, allowing the
problem to get out of control. They are particularly angry with companies that are looking for cheap labor partially explaining why this is happening.
• Opposition to non-essential benefits. The public’s leading concern about illegal immigration is that the immigrants get access to non-essential government benefits at a time when government spending is squeezed and taxes are a burden. There is strong opposition to Medicaid, taxpayer-subsidized health care, for illegal immigrants. But they are also strongly opposed to drivers’ licenses, an implicit
recognition of legal status and claim on benefits.
• Support for emergency health care and education. Most Americans accept access to emergency health care for illegal immigrants and education through high school for the children of illegal immigrants who are U.S. citizens.
• Positive views of new immigrants. Negative attitudes toward immigrants combine with a lot of respect – many in a new survey describing them as ‘hard working,’ ‘family-oriented’ and ‘trying to be good citizens.’ That creates an opening for an
inclusive approach, based on America’s strength as an immigrant nation. There is strong support, for example, for undocumented immigrants in the U.S. military being able to win nearly immediate citizenship.
• Toward a solution: responsibility and a path to citizenship. A large majority of voters support a path to citizenship if we are serious about having to qualify for citizenship: expelling anyone who has committed a crime, others pay a fine and
taxes, learn English, and get in the back of the queue. But if voters hear only the part about a path to citizenship without the responsibilities, they do not support this – and punish incumbent Democrats. But if Democrats ‘get it’ and are very serious about getting the problem under control, including benefits, their leaders can get support for solving this problem in ways consistent with our values.”
This poll clearly shows that voters all believe that immigration is good for America as long as it does legally. But voters are desperate for leaders who take responsibility and really solve problems. Voters are so desperate for action that they will listen to anyone willing to talk about this issue, even to folks who want to create an atmosphere of division instead of tangible solutions such has Corey Stewart did in Prince William this year.
Also Democrats cannot afford to reward illegal behavior such has handing out driver’s licenses to illegal immigrants such ahs the plan proposed by New York Democrats. What Democrats must do is let voters hear decisively “that we get it and want to get things under control – and then, the solution that restores our lawful immigrant tradition.” Once we do this Democrats will win this issue and continue to win more and more races as time goes by.